top of page

The Limits of Heart Rate Training for Amateur Triathletes (and What to Do Instead)

Feb 15, 2024
2 min read

Updated: Nov 2

Heart rate training is popular, and for good reason: it can help you pace your efforts and avoid overdoing it. But for amateur athletes, and especially newer age-group triathletes, relying on heart rate alone often isn't the best approach. Here's why, and what to do instead.

1. Your zones may be wrong from the start

Heart rate zones are built on a number, usually your maximum heart rate or your lactate threshold heart rate. The common 220-minus-age formula for max heart rate can be off by 15 to 20 beats or more, as I explained in Run by Heart Rate or RPE? Without a proper field test, many amateurs end up training at the wrong intensity, which leads to slow progress or overtraining.

2. Heart rate changes with more than effort

Heat, dehydration, stress, caffeine, poor sleep, fatigue and illness all push your heart rate up or down. So does cardiac drift: on long sessions your heart rate slowly climbs even when your pace or power stays the same. Newer athletes often don't account for this and misread their numbers.

3. Heart rate lags behind your effort

Your watch shows heart rate in real time, but your heart takes 30 seconds to a couple of minutes to catch up to a change in effort. That makes heart rate a poor guide for short intervals, hills and surges. By the time it reaches your target zone, the interval may be half over.

4. Wearables aren't always accurate

Wrist-based optical sensors can be thrown off by a loose fit, cold skin, arm movement, tattoos and water. Chest straps are much more accurate, especially for intervals. If your data looks strange, the sensor may be the problem, not you.

5. Heart rate ignores how you feel

Heart rate doesn't capture perceived effort. Athletes who ignore how they feel and chase a number can push too hard on bad days or hold back on good ones. Your rate of perceived exertion (RPE) is a valuable training signal in its own right.

6. Zone training takes know-how

Using zones well means understanding what each one is for and applying them consistently. Many amateurs end up doing most sessions at the same moderate effort, too hard for easy days and too easy for hard days, and miss the benefits of varied intensity.

What to do instead

Heart rate is a useful tool, just not the only one. Combine it with:

  • RPE: learn how each effort feels, using the talk test.

  • Pace: for running and swimming, especially in intervals.

  • Power: on the bike, a power meter or smart trainer gives instant, accurate feedback.

And get guidance from an experienced coach who can set your zones from a proper test and teach you to read your body. If you have questions, reach out, or check out my triathlon coaching options.

Marques Garcia

Comments


bottom of page